(Mou) It has been a long time since the last update but there was something that happened last week that is probably worth blogging about.
Addy and I were on our way to meet Qing Qing, Wenting, Sulin and Yirong last Friday after salsa class at Jitterbugs. We were waiting for the bus to come at the bus stop outside Palais Renaissance; and there were two guys in their late teens or early-20s sitting in front of us. One was just a normal guy listening to his mp3 player, while the other guy looked somewhat mentally disabled or something. The latter was looking around helplessly and seemed to be in genuine need of help. He was clutching a small sling bag, with three bottles of water, his ez-link card and some money in a small makeshift wallet. He took out a card and handed it to mp3 guy, all the while glancing around in slight panic and looking at me and Addy like he was asking us to help us. We reached down for the card and it read roughly like: “Melvyn Tan is a deaf-mute; and is slightly intellectually-disabled. If he shows you this card, he needs some help getting home. He stays at Sengkang Blk 123, and needs to take bus no. 80, 123, 456, 789 to go home. Please let him know when the bus arrives and help him get on the bus. *Please do not give him any money!!!*” The problem was, none of the buses at that particular bus stop are those on the card. He probably made a wrong turn somewhere and ended up lost, and could not find his way back home. What would you have done in this situation?
Addy looked at me like I have the answer, as I usually do, so I bo pian have to come up with something. No, seriously, he could take the bus together with us to Bugis, and take 80 from there to go home. Addy seemed pleased with the answer and told him, partly in sign language indicating that the buses on his card do not come to this bus stop and he needed to change bus and take two buses to get home. Somehow, the time I took to think of a solution and subsequent discussion with Addy frightened him, and he grabbed his card back and acted as if he did not even talk to us. I was a little confused by his actions, and the bus came for us to go to Bugis, so I told Addy that we can try to ask him to take the bus with us and change bus at Bugis; if he doesn’t want to follow us there is really nothing much we can do. So we tried telling him to board the bus with us – but he knows that is not the right bus to take! He refused to come along with us; and I told Addy there is really nothing much we can do, moreover, we are late meeting the girls and whatever we try he is unlikely to follow because he has become wary of us. Thus, we boarded the bus and left him at the bus stop by himself.
Addy was troubled by what we did; and in truth I was too. She asked me twice on the bus, is there really nothing else we can do? Can’t we call the police or something? I told her honestly what I thought at that moment: yes, there might be something else we can do like help him flag a taxi or call the police but (1) he is unwilling to come with us, so even if we flag a taxi he might not want to come in and (2) we are late to meet the girls and (3) I believe that Singaporeans are unlikely to take advantage of him unlike many other places in the world I have been like in Latin America, where he would probably get robbed if he was lucky, or kidnapped and killed if he wasn’t. Addy asked again, why can’t we be the ones calling the police, why must it be someone else? Actually honestly I had no really good answer to that, but at that moment I honestly felt that he would show the card to someone else later again and someone will think of something and find a way to solve his problem. Admittedly, I did not have a solution for him myself, and I believed that someone else will come up with something later, so we carried on our journey to meet the girls.
Did I feel bad about it, leaving him stranded there, lost, confused, tired, afraid? Yes, and it troubled me later. Did I have a better alternative at that particular moment? No, and I honestly had faith that someone else will come up with a solution for him later. Was it really our responsibility to help him? Maybe; but maybe his caregivers should bear greater responsibility for leaving him in that predicament; but maybe he wanted to be independent and got into that predicament himself; we tried what we could to help him, and he did not want our help, what else could we do? Were we wrong to leave him there alone? Would you have done things differently?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)